Effective CNC router design is a complex engineering endeavor.  Every company that enters this competitive field faces a similar set of daunting challenges.  How do they build a system that is dependable, durable, simple to use and consistently delivers smooth cuts at high speeds.

Whether you’re designing or evaluating a system it is important to realize a CNC router is only as good as its weakest link.  You can build a system with the finest mechanical components, but if you utilize an unstable electronic control, you won’t end up with a very good machine.  Or, a machine can be constructed with a quality controller and the best of drive train components, but if the foundation of the machine doesn’t provide sufficient rigidity, your machine's performance will be substantially compromised  To effectively evaluate a CNC system requires looking at the total picture.

 

Blue takes you to the correct page- Red to the subject of interest on that page.

 

Machine Base

The machine base is the part of a CNC router structure that supports the system drive train, gantry, work surface and so on.  It should be constructed in a manner that provides a stable foundation which yields superior rigidity, dampens vibrations, resists flex and maintains dimensional stability.

Techno machine bases are designed for the dynamics of high speed operation.  They provide the necessary stability and dampening to resist the deflection and vibration caused by CNC movement and cutting forces.  Additionally, the Techno bases are dimensionally stable; they start out square, level and accurate and stay that way.  

Within the Techno line, all floor models (LC, LCX, RG, Panel Master & Premium) feature the industry standard construction method for CNC Router machine bases; precision ground steel components joined together with stress relieved weldments.  Joining two or more pieces of metal together with weldments is the only way of making them act as a single piece.

Competitive Consideration- in contrast to a welded steel, stressed relieved machine base construction method, a number of lower cost CNC systems feature bolted assembly machine bases.  Inherit in such assemblies are several negative characteristics. In establishing joints in a bolted assembly the contact area between components (bolted area) is generally only about 15-20% of the contact area resulting from a weldment.  Obviously, this makes for a weaker joint.  Additionally, when the bolts are tightened, stresses are introduced into the steel which cause the structure to twist and creep on an ongoing basis.  And, when a machine base shifts position (creeps and twists) every linked component is pulled with it; guideways, bearings and so on.  The result is a machine that’s neither square, level or accurate.

 

Drive Train

The term drive train on a CNC router refers to the group of components that transforms rotary action into linear motion.  It is comprised of bearings (plane or rolling element) guide-ways and some means of moving the system from one point to another, generally a screw or rack.  A drive train should be able to withstand extreme environments, feature a low coefficient of friction, and reliably provide precise, high-speed performance with minimal user maintenance.

 

 

 

 

Techno’s CNC Routers utilize THK precision ground steel rails, linear bearings and ball screw drives.  This combination provides smooth high-speed performance; requiring minimal maintenance and excellent accuracy and extremely long life.  Techno drive trains feature the following characteristics:

 

 

 

Critical Y-Axis Drive Train (drive train responsible for gantry structure movement –front/back motion)

On all Techno systems the ball screw is positioned in the middle of the axis, this eliminates the possibility of racking (structural twisting).  Additionally, this drive is mounted under the system work table which provides an effective shield against debris and contaminants.  The Y-Axis features recirculating anti-friction linear bearings and precision ground/hardened steel rails which are engineered to provide the requisite stiffness and high load capacity to negate gantry skew when heavy cuts are taken at the edge of the table. Precision alignment of the guideway system during machine assembly guarantees maximum feedrates, accuracy and excellent overall life expectancy.

 

 

The Y-Axis ball screw ends are rigidly fixed and the ball nut is rotated allowing Techno’s small diameter high-performance screw/anti-backlash nut combination to operate well above critical speed without encountering problems with screw whip.

 

 

X-Axis Drive Train (responsible for side to side motion)     Z-Axis Drive Train (responsible for up/down motion)

On all Techno systems the X/Z Axis drive trains are housed in a rigid anodized aluminum extrusion profile which is scratch/corrosion resistant and features an internal reinforced webbing to provide maximum stability; the drive trains incorporates a fully enclosed servo motor assembly fitted with plastic seals to guard against contaminants entering the internal mechanism.

The Z Axis drive train utilizes a wide base which is well suited for cantilevered loads (spindles, drill banks, etc.).  Designed for rigid, high load capacity the drives features: precision ground/hardened steel rails, recirculating anti-friction linear bearings and Techno’s small diameter, high-performance ball screws and anti-backlash ball nutsPrecision alignment of the guideway system during machine assembly guarantees maximum feedrates, accuracy and excellent overall life expectancy

 

Rack & Pinion/Ball Screw Comparison

The two most common drives today are the rack and the ball screw. A rack and pinion is one of the least expensive methods of generating linear motion from rotary motion. The rack consists of a long steel bar into which gear teeth have been cut. The drive motor turns a pinion gear that is meshed into this rack. As the gear turns, it rolls up and down the rack moving the axis.

While most rack and pinion drives feature the advantages of being simple and inexpensive, they also have some notable limitations. The motor must turn at a reasonably high speed to generate the required power. It must therefore drive the pinion gear through a gear reduction box.  The gearbox required to drive the pinion gear is generally not more than 75% efficient and in many cases far less. This means that a significant amount of the available motor power is used to overcome friction in the system.  Friction increases wear, lowers a system’s speed, acceleration and positional accuracy.  If you loosen the gears up to decrease friction you introduce additional backlash. If you tighten the system to eliminate backlash you increase friction and decrease performance.

The most common configuration for rack and pinion systems is a dual drive train (see graphic directly below) on a machine’s long axis.  Rack and pinion assemblies are mounted on each side of the gantry and each assembly is powered by its own motor.  This configuration is sometimes touted as providing superior performance under large off center loads then can be attained with a single drive train mounted in the middle of the axis.  Fact is, single ball screw drive trains that are middle axis mounted, when engineered properly, provide the requisite stiffness and high load capacity to negate gantry skew when heavy cuts are taken at the edge of the table.  They’ve been doing this successfully for decades.

Of course, when two drive trains are utilized to run one axis, both drive trains always have to move in concert. If the motors or the alignment of the two rack drives do not stay in sync it can put a significant strain on the system, causing a decline in performance, cut quality and drive train service life. 

A ball screw and nut combination is the most common drive means for CNC routers. It is also widely acknowledged as the best and most efficient CNC drive. The nut is actually a bearing that turns on the screw with very little friction. The ball nut is mounted to the part of the machine that is to move and the screw is mounted to the base. As the screw turns, it moves the ball nut and the axis it is connected to.  A variation of this configuration is to rigidly fix the ends of the screw and rotate the ball nut instead.  All Techno CNC units feature rigidity mounted ball screw drives and anti-backlash nuts

Ball screws have a number of advantages over racks.  A ball screw has excellent power transmission (90-95% efficiency) due to the rolling-ball contact between the nut and screws. So, ball screw based drive trains don't have the friction problems that are inherit with rack based drive trains.  Motor power in a ball screw drive is used to move the system, not consumed overcoming drive train friction. Keeping fraction to a minimum contributes substantially to responsive operation and long -term maintenance-free operation.  Additionally, ball screws don’t have the play or the requirement for adjustments that racks do; they also do not wear as easily as racks, they are far less likely to get debris in the mechanism than racks (debris in a drive train can cause skipping and errant motion) and by the nature of the differences in mechanical engagement ball screws run smoother.